Two much-used buzz words of our age.
If you ever wondered whether the ‘fake news’ phenomenon was just hype, today’s newspapers should reassure you that you have every reason to be concerned.
It’s in every news outlet (which, needless to say, doesn’t guarantee it’s true) – the UK Government has been exposed, using dodgy figures to bolster its position on immigration. The Home Office previously estimated there were 100,000 foreign students a year staying on in Britain illegally – but new data from the Office of National Statistics says there were only 4,600 last year.
“We spent five years trying to persuade the Home Office that the figures they were using as evidence were bogus,” said the Lib Dem leader, Vince Cable, who was part of the coalition under David Cameron. “But they persisted nonetheless on the basis of these phoney numbers.”
We know how this happened. The government was under pressure from UKIP and felt they needed to be tougher on immigration. So pluck a figure from the air and ‘hey presto’ we’re as tough as they are. You have to laugh. The evidence is the servant of the policy, not the other way around. It’s like the police searching single-mindedly for the evidence to convict the guy they’ve already decided is guilty. Evidence-based policy.
So now we know they just make shit up on this subject, how confident are we about the evidence base for other policies?
‘£350 million extra for the NHS’ anyone?
Be very afraid.